What the exam asks
Every question on Topic 4.7 tests one of three core historical developments within the themes of Social Interactions and Organization (SIO) and Governance (GOV), often using the reasoning process of continuity and change:
- Managing diversity: How and why some empires accommodated ethnic and religious minorities while others suppressed or expelled them.
- Rise of new elites: How imperial conquests and global trade created new ruling or wealthy classes (such as Manchu bannermen in Qing China, peninsulares and creoles in the Americas, and European urban entrepreneurs).
- Fluctuating power of existing elites: How traditional landed aristocracies lost autonomy to centralizing monarchs.
Core ideas
Accommodation versus suppression of diversity
Expanding empires ruled over subjects of varied faiths and ethnicities. Rulers chose between pragmatic tolerance—using the economic and administrative skills of minorities—and forced uniformity.
| Empire / State | Policy Approach | Specific Historical Examples (c. 1450–c. 1750) |
|---|---|---|
| Ottoman Empire | Accommodation (mostly) | Organized religious minorities (Christians, Jews) into self-governing millets in exchange for the jizya tax; welcomed Sephardic Jews expelled from Spain (1492), utilizing their commercial, medical, and printing skills. Women in the royal harem (like Roxelana) also wielded significant political influence. |
| Mughal Empire | Accommodation Suppression | Akbar (r. 1556–1605) abolished the jizya tax on non-Muslims, funded Hindu temples, and married Rajput princesses. Later, Aurangzeb (r. 1658–1707) reinstated the jizya and restricted Hindu practices, sparking rebellions. |
| Spain & Portugal | Suppression | Spain issued the Alhambra Decree (1492) expelling Jews who refused to convert to Catholicism (followed by Portugal’s expulsion edict in 1496) and later forced Muslims to convert or leave; both states used the Inquisition to police converts (conversos and moriscos). |
| Qing China | Suppression & Separation | The minority Manchu conquerors banned intermarriage with the majority Han Chinese, reserved the highest government posts for Manchus, and forced Han men to wear the braided queue hairstyle as a visible sign of submission. |